First off, the subscription service will NOT include this Discussion Board. It will remain free and available to anyone who wants to sign up for an account.
And secondly, thanks for all your input. While the subscription service has launched, it's still very much in its early stages and so everyone involved with it (including The Baldy) is very open to ideas on how to make it a great fan club (though sorry, we can't make it free).
I'm glad the idea of contests was mentioned. We do plan on having subscriber-only contests that will feature prizes like autographed merch. The idea of a subscribers' only t-shirt is also under serious consideration.
The idea of some kind of holiday and birthday greeting is a good one too. I bet we can arrange that.
As for any ideas that involve tickets and live shows and meet and greets, I will pass those onto the band's management since those ideas are a little more complicated than a t-shirt or discount at the Store. Right now I have no idea if Alice will be back on the road in 2008 but if they are, we can hopefully arrange something special for our subscribers.