Down III has to be Album of the Year as far as I'm concerned. Phil really sings his heart out on it from dealing with Dime's death, Katrina, and getting clean. Just a great solid album. I've got tickets to see them on the 26th and I can't wait.
I don't understand why some people don't like the second one. NOLA, Bustle in Your Hedgegrove, and Over the Under are all great albums.